« Excerpt from “The Muse of Revolution” | Main | A Deeply American Experience: Excerpt from Jefferson’s Pillow »

July 03, 2010

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00e54ed2b7aa88330133f2046c96970b

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Fourth of July in the Borderlands: Praying for Rain:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Ms February

Your post makes an egregious error not at all uncommon to people outside of Arizona who presume to know the illegal immigrant issue better than those of us who have lived here for years - years of Federal indifference, it should not be forgotten.
The error of your post is in blaming increased border patrolling for increased deaths amongst border crossers. That perspective can only be the result of coming to the issue with a very subjective position.
The reason that more border crossers are dying in the desert is because ... they are coming here ILLEGALLY ... and thus choosing the most dangerous corridor at the most dangerous time of the year.
How many legal immigrant deaths in the desert are tallied? None. Because they're not knowingly violating this nation's immigration laws and as such are not trying to avoid anything.
Perhaps you should look up the terms "rape tree"; "torture house"; and "kidnapping" - Phoenix has become the kidnapping capital of America. And many of these migrants looking merely for work are tortured and even murdered in the fight between coyotes trying to establish turf as well as extorting families back in Mexico.
Can you please explain what is wrong with waiting in line, like all the people from other countries trying to come to America?

Jessie

Just an editorial note in response to this comment: Margaret Regan, the author of this post, does not write as an "outsider" to the problems facing Arizona. She has lived in Tucson since 1986, and was formerly a staff writer for the Tucson Weekly.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Our Community

Beacon Press on Scribd

About Beacon Broadside

  • Beacon Broadside, a project of Beacon Press, is an online venue for essays, news items, and dispatches from respected writers, thinkers, and activists about our times.
  • Read More | Fine Print | Contact
Subscribe to Beacon BroadsideVisit the Beacon Press Facebook Fan Page

Categories

Related Posts with Thumbnails