Joe Nocera's Fracking Rorschach Test
October 08, 2013
By Philip Warburg. This post originally appeared on his blog.
In the October 5th edition of the New York Times, columnist Joe Nocera—a self-avowed fracking enthusiast—seeks to allay environmental concerns about the greenhouse gas emissions from natural gas fracking operations. He cites a study released last month by a group of scientists at the University of Texas that found on-site methane leakage at fracking wells to be lower than previous studies had assumed. According to this study, only 0.42% of the gas produced by fracking ends up in the air as "upstream" methane emissions—i.e. gas releases at and around the wellhead.
Nocera reassures readers that the companies cooperating with and supporting the U. Texas study "in many cases were using the best available well-completion technology" at the studied sites. Good for them. But how representative are they of the half-a-million or more fracking operations now stretching across dozens of states, often run by small, independent companies with little effective government oversight?
Physicians & Engineers for Healthy Energy, an independent group of professionals that formed in response to New York State's fracking boom, offers a useful critique of the micro-sampling methodology and other flaws in the U. Texas study. It's worth the read.
Also worth reading is a new report by the Conservation Law Foundation, looking at the massive "downstream" leakage of methane through our poorly maintained and under-monitored gas distribution network. In my home state of Massachusetts alone, the report says 8 to 12 billion cubic feet of methane are released into the atmosphere each year from leaky distribution lines. As methane is 20 times more powerful than CO2 as a greenhouse gas, this neglected infrastructure is not just wasting a valuable fuel; it's a major contributor to global warming.Philip Warburg is the author of Harvest the Wind. His writings have appeared in numerous policy journals and newspapers including the New York Times, the Boston Globe, and the Washington Post. He lives and works in Newton, Massachusetts.